The Court of Appeal ruled that the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) can interrogate witnesses beyond office hours.
The decision of the three-man Bench, comprising Justices Hasan Lah, Ahmad Maarop and Syed Ahmad Helmy Syed Ahmad, was unanimous.
Once again, the High Court has been overruled by the Court of Appeal, in a case brought by the opposition against the establishment.
“There is nothing in the provision to say that ‘day to day’ is restricted to normal working hours,” he noted.
But the three-men bench failed to define what the term should mean, a point which lawyer Karpal Singh, acting for Tan, pounced on.
“The Court of Appeal did not say what ‘day to day’ means. We are still in doubt,” Karpal told reporters later.
“Are they saying it’s round the clock? If it’s round the clock, it will lead to serious complications,” he added, and pointed that the administration of justice will be compromised.
Yes, the verdict is weird, incomplete and inconclusive. The judges should have defined what 'day to day' should mean. Judges should also observe common sense in their judgement. This is the basis of natural justice.
Weird. Maybe we should use the money for BTN courses to conduct more training programmes for those holding important public offices to avoid more flip-flops.
19 comments:
BN MEANS- BARISAN NAIK SEBAB GST NAIK,CORRUPTION NAIK,JUDICIARY TAK BOLEH PAKAI NAIK,ORANG TAHANAN OLEH PDRM KEBANYAKAN MATI TANPA SEBAB YANG KUKUH NAIK,MACCC INTEERKOREK TENGAH MALAM KERJAPUN NAIK SAMPAI ORANG DIBUNUH OLEH AHMAD SAID BAPA KEPADA ANAK PORNO.BABI PUNYA BINATANG,SPR PULA NAIK JADI ANJING UMNO .SATU COCLUSION BN (BARISAN NONOK).BN (BEEend)
The very basic principle of law of "Substance Over Form" does not seem to prevail in our beloved country.
It's a very sad and dark episode that the nation is going through.
Hopefully all this kind of decision will one day be their own peril.
Disgusting!!!
Here in BolehLand, it really makes no difference which court it is, one can over-rule the other in quick time especially when it's case against the Establishment so why waste everybody's time and resources? Just have one court, call it COA Court and that's it!
Malaysians are truly sick of what's going on in the country!
This country is so fucked up!!
that they uses women to fuck with men to produce babies for sale.
We have been all fucked up 22 years by mamakthir who uses fuck on saiful's ass so that he can fuck up his deputy.
Fucked up laws and
Fucked up accounting standards who never reports irregularities and
Fucked up house and road planning
Fucked up architects who built for munney
Fucked up education system
Fucked prostituition and gambling rings
Fucked up police officers
Fucked up greedy politicians
Fucked up doctors who doesnt seem to know anything
Fucked up people with ambitions to fuck the country upside down
Excuse me for the language but this is the only way to describe
"1 REALLY FUCKED UP MALAYSIA"
WHEN ARE THE PEOPLE FUCKING GONNA GROW UP ? UNTIL THE JAPANESE COMES TO INVADE ? UNTIL THE BRITS COME AND TELL US WHAT TO DO ? UNTIL THE PORTUGESE CONTROL OUR PORTS ? UNTIL HANG TUAH RESSURECTS ?
COME ON LA ITS TIME TO REALLY GROW UP MALAYSIANS WHO ARE NOT ONLY SPOONFED EVERYDAY BUT RATHER BREASTFED!!!
YOU GOTTA BE ASHAMED OF YOURSELVES
Everyone knows that the court of Appeals are run by stooges of UMNO who were fast-tracked to head this important arm of the judiciary.
Now you can see the reason this was done ; so that UMNO can overturn any decisions made by the High Court on cases that goes against them.
Really sad day for Malaysians who demand real justice.
Still remember you were reminded not to get excited over the decision by the High Court over the Perak fiasco?
And true it is the next day with speed lightning the decison is overruled.
What are you waiting ?
Let me try,
day to day = round the clock = merry go round? Oops, quick go n grab a dictionarylah!!
It is plainly written on the wall.You want to play games, I will play along with you lah!
court of appeal judges? you know why they are in that position. meritocracy? justice my foot. Memang 1 Malaysia Boleh.
How come all our High Court judges so poor ones-always made mistakes decisions that need to be corrected by the Court Appeal judges.Shouldnt they be sacked for incompetence?.
In several hot cases recently, almost all the cases are overuled by court of appeal.
i wonder why such situation occur so often? High court & Federal court judges should be the experienced judges which are promoted from the low level court, isn't it?
So, they are professional & experienced, their judgement should be alligned with the law after they have praticed as judge for long times.
But, look like their judgement are easily overuled by Court of Appeal. The problem raised here, are they really not to the standard until often overuled by Court of Appeal or the other way round? If court of appeal are so good, then put them into Federal or High Court as judge, and do the right judegement, fire the unqualified judge that always judge differently. Don't need to waste tax payers money.
if the judgement always flip flop in different courts, how can RAKYAT confidence to out judicial system???
It's now look like court of jungle!!!
Lately we see quite many cases where appeal court overruled high court. It is difficult for layman like me to comprehend. Can anyone explain ?
WHY macc staff can torture suspects
after 5.30 pm causing one mati through the tingkap !?
...so dat OT wages & allowances can be claimed ma !
WHY no polis & hospital be contacted
immediately !?
...got vital meeting with vvips ma !
WHY & why ?
...to plan 'wat & how' to do ma !
@#$%^&* !
...samasama !!
Overturning the High Court decision is easy but providing the legal rationale for that decision seems to be the difficult part for our learned Court of Appeal judges.
I'd have to agree with Karpal Singh that they CoA judges should then determine what "day-to-day" means.
I have a feeling that if this goes up to the highest court, they might still refuse to give a determination of what "day-to-day" is to be interpreted as.
But isn't that the duty of judges i.e to interpret the law ?
I agree that the High Court should be closed down since they always made mistakes,don't burden the Court of appeal judges
When the judges gave vertict in favour of pakatan, they are heros.
When the judges gave verdict in favour of BN, they are corrupted.
honesty is a rare commodity in malaysia. In 1996 , an honest judge wrote about the sad state of affairs in the judiciary and corrupt practices among the bench. He was forced to resign - an honourable man name Syed Ahmad Idid _ an honest judge. Today we seen pictures of a lawyer and a top judge holidaying overseas. This act is acceptable in our nation. Malaysia Boleh
Have u heard of COL ? If the COA is still not effective then this is the last resort.
Kalah tetap kalah or Menang tetap menang.
court of lanun.
Post a Comment