Friday, January 15, 2010

New Putrajaya Directive on the Use of 'Allah' & Political Desperation

Christians in the two Malaysian Borneo states can continue to use the term 'Allah' for God in Malay print as they have done for the last 300 years.

The federal government however still sees no reason why Christians in Peninsular Malaysia should use the term 'Allah' for God even in Malay print, and East Malaysians resident in the Peninsula have to respect the prohibition.

The new directive on the use of 'Allah' is both silly and outrageous. Can this directive be implemented? This directive has created more confusion than trying to solve the current impasse.

What term should the East Malaysians traveling to West Malaysia use in their prayers?

This directive is just a political decision to mitigate Barisan's damaged integrity in both Sabah and Sarawak, which were seen as it political fixed deposits.

“Christians in Sabah and Sarawak need not worry over this issue because it is a common tradition there. I have been to an Iban church service and I heard 'Allah' used there,” Nazri said. Here, Nazri has shown his biggest hypocrisy. Why didn't he tell the government so at the very start of the ban?

Asked why the need for two sets of rules on the usage of the word, he stressed that this is not a unique practice as Malaysia also has two sets of laws on other matters, citing the syariah court and the civil court as examples.

Nazri's attempt to equate the two set of directives on the use of 'Allah' to the syariah and civil courts is another example of his lack of knowledge about the rule of law. Under the constitution, the civil court is the supreme court and not syariah court. How can this be an apple to apple comparison?

Is Nazri even fit to speak on behalf of the government on this issue?

23 comments:

wong said...

i am amazed the lack of courage to make a decision .it is either yes or no.there are no 2 ways about it.when the shit hit the fans...these goons are quick to compromise..i wondered one day when we are faced with a bigger force .these be the 1st to sell out for 30 gold coins

Jong said...

LOL!!!!!!
How silly can those UMNO politicians get. I have not even got over this:

" Sultan Selangor mahu kerajaan negeri halang bukan Islam guna kalimah ‘Allah’."

Soon they may even make it law that "Allah" is not allowed mention during Friday Christian prayers by East Malaysians, Friday a holy day reserved solely for Muslims alone.

KAKAKAKAKKA!!! ...jokers!

Anonymous said...

Looks like a band-aid solution. What will happen if Sabahan amd Sarawakian Christian so used to the word ' Allah' come over to Peninsula Malaysia. Will they have to stop using 'Allah'?. I will not be surprise that it will be another flip-flop decision. 1 Malaysia, 2 Gods.

foo wy len said...

" How can this be an apple to apple comparision?" Why not? In this wonderful land of ours anything goes. To some smart people of Min Of Hihger Edu. apple and orange are actually the same. remember the university intake fiasco that based on Matriculation and STPM not too long ago? To the same smart people orange are in fact better apple! How pathetic!

Samuel Goh Kim Eng said...

DON'T PLAY STUPID PRANK

Don't ever try to be a silly crank
Trying to play a dangerous sick prank
For soon you may be walking the plank
Or get thrown inside the prison tank

(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng - 150110
http://MotivationInMotion.blogspot.com
Fri. 15th Jan. 2010.

Anonymous said...

Maintaining the historical status quo for East Malaysia and forbidding the use of the A word in peninsular Malaysia (let alone how it is to be implemented) is not a solution at all.

If anything, Malaysia will be perceived internationally as practicing an irrational double standard for the sake of appeasing the extremists.

Anonymous said...

Looks like UMNO is utterly confused and does not know why it is against the use of the word Allah by Christians.
First they said it will confuse Muslims.
Then they claimed its Christians way of converting Muslims.
Then they said Allah is a a Muslim God and Christians cannot use them.
Now they say eat can, west cannot.

Anonymous said...

For how long will the East Malaysians be able to continue with the usage before the next bigot start to rant again? This country is looking more and more silly by the day. It reflects on the type of leadership we have. This put to rest the 1Malaysia mantra is all hot air and meaningless mumbo jumbo from Najib.

Anonymous said...

Since East Malaysia have different terminology,

Why not make it a different country as well ?

NAZRI - You must study hard

Whack_Job said...

The "allow East and not Peninsula" decision is solving the problem of angry people.

It doesn't solve the issue of whether Christians can use the word "Allah".

If there is a date in our country's history that should guide our decisions, it is 13 May 1969. Back then we said, things must change, discriminatory policies must exist. But it was a solution designed to appease an angry society rather than solving the question of "why one race can do it and another can't?".

40 years later, racial walls are higher than ever. Did we not learn after 40 years?

Anonymous said...

The minister in the PM's dept DS Nazri Aziz is talking nuts by saying the Kalimah Allah can be used by Christians in Sarawak and Sabah. UMNO and BN made blunders in ruling the country for half a century. They are on the way to be booted out in the next general elections. Now they will do anything to get support but is not working. They are prepared to even compromise on the use of Kalimah Allah by others. DS Nazri, how can this govt rule the country by having 2 sets of regulations for the same matter, that is one for peninsular and the other for Sabah & Sarawak. Tak sedar lagikah Nazri. Di mana iman hang?

Samuel Goh Kim Eng said...

EAST YES WEST NO

People are puzzled by any divergent rule
When they don't have all the hidden clues
Why strangely suddenly out of the blues
There's no longer the known religious glue

(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng - 160110
http://MotivationInMotion.blogspot.com
Sat. 16th Jan. 2010.

Samuel Goh Kim Eng said...

WRONG DEGREE WITH BIASED DECREE

Do not smile with glee
Over any biased decree
That causes good things to flee
Faster than the flight of bumble bees

(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng - 160110
http://MotivationInMotion.blogspot.com
Sat. 16th Jan. 2010.

Samuel Goh Kim Eng said...

TOUGH WHIPPING NOW

Forget about any form of whipping
Mental torture is punishment enough
With some many matters already slipping
No need for any public show of being rough

(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng - 160110
http://MotivationInMotion.blogspot.com
Sat. 16th Jan. 2010.

Anonymous said...

Don't we have such "smart" Ministers in our country...???? Errr... what was that motto that's insisted on that says we are united?

Oh yah..... 1Malaysia..!

Stir it all up.... & the saviour is me!!!

For the world to see & judge for all the wrong reasons "AGAIN"...!!!
Please, enough lah...!!!

Sudah sudah cukup malu brother..!

Samuel Goh Kim Eng said...

WRONG STRATEGY CAN LEAD TO TRAGEDY

Please don't use the 'divide and rule' strategy
For it may bring about undesirable, unwanted tragedy
Wiser to use a better instrument to play a new melody
Before we qualify to become the world's biggest comedy

(C) Samuel Goh Kim Eng - 170110
http://MotivationInMotion.blogspot.com
SUN. 17th Jan. 2010.

wandererAUS said...

WHEN WE HAVE THE “kING OF UMNO JOKERS” COMING OUT WITH HIS LASTEST DIRECTIVE ON THE USAGE OF ALLAH IN EAST MALAYSIA, HE HAS COMPLICATED THE Allah controversy EVEN FURTHER.
MUSLIM ALLAH MUST BE GETTING CRAZY!!!

clearwater said...

This is as stupid as it gets. Even Nazri has outdone himself this time around.The fact that a cabinet ranked Minister from Umno is floating the idea of a compromise is evidence enough of their concern on their flimsy vote losing stand.

This Allah issue is all about politics, pure and simple. I really hope the people of Sarawak and Sabah now have their eyes prised open and that BN loses their East Malaysian vote bank with this arrogant blunder.

Anonymous said...

sorry to say this but shariah court is actually at the same status as civil courts after the constitution was amended several years ago

Anonymous said...

This Naz policy indirectly confirmed what BN's been saying all these while. That many among them "brainless, moral-less & logic-less" will be easily confused while the rest of us esp. from S&S aren't.

Hence in peninsular, no one else should use the A-word and confuse their already very confused mind.

Pardon me if this argument make no sense to you, I'm also blur ans confused now!

Anonymous said...

That "OXFART" cunning and apportunistic bull is at its wit again. This time trying to be a hero trying to teach religious issueS to East Malaysians. Just the look at him will make one puke. BN Youth the model for the younger generation to follow? No, thanks. This is the same group of goons who, until recently, were wielding keris while threatening other races and physically harassed wheelchair-bound DAP leader Karpal Singh in Parliament.
Hey, you "oxfart" bull, please don't 'kacau' East Malaysians. The people who created the tension are not from the East.
What makes us East Malaysians proud is that we do not play racial and religious politics. Look at Sabah and Sarawak: when we campaign for elections, we never use racial issue to gain support. We do not make racist remarks and attack other races. Only West Malaysians play such a dangerous and selfish game. "Oxfart", please don't bring in your racist and religious game to East Malaysia.
Get your dirty hands off Sabah and Sarawak. We do not need you and your extremists to come and colonise us. First, the chief minister's post was rotated among the BN component parties. Then, Umno said that only the dominant party could take the CM's post.
The Sabahans now realise this and will kick them out in the next general election. The Allah row should not have happened, but Umno started it, and now they have shot themselves in the foot. This is a blessing in disguise for Sabah and Sarawak.
Just kick this "Oxfart" and his goons out before they create racial and religious tensions in our "Land Of PEACE". We have enough from you guys.

Anonymous said...

I say, why is this chap Samuel Goh keep on spamming this blog? What a loser he is. Pay for commercial advertising. This forum does not have room for joker like Samuel, eh? Guess what, Samuel? The childish way of getting free publicity on this blog is a sure sign of real DE-motivation. Anthony Robins you ain't mate. Get real, Samuel and go get a life!

Anonymous said...

i've heard of something why he 'has' to retire early as a principal in a secondary school in ipoh la !!